Case Summary:

Ukrainian customs authorities temporarily seized a substantial consignment of excise goods belonging to Philip Morris. Despite court rulings in favour of the company, the goods were never returned due to violations committed by state officials, ultimately resulting in their loss.

Outcome:

The Commercial Court of Kyiv held the state liable for the damages and ordered the recovery of UAH 30,176,657.41 (approx. EUR 720,400) from the state budget in favour of Philip Morris.

Significance:

The court effectively reaffirmed the principle that the state must be held accountable for the unlawful actions of its officials and that such liability is unavoidable. It upheld the inviolability of property rights and the necessity of protection against arbitrary interference with those rights—even by state authorities and their representatives.

Resorting to the commercial court remains an effective means for business entities to defend their infringed rights and legally protected interests.

We are grateful to Philip Morris for their trust. This court decision serves as an important signal to businesses and citizens alike: when rights are violated, they can and must be defended in court.

ArsLegem Law Firm continues to actively represent corporate clients in complex judicial and pre-trial disputes, offering deep expertise, effective strategies, and the highest standards of legal service and professional support.